Tokyo, Nov. 19 (Jiji Press)–Disputes in Japan over ambiguous handwritten ballots in two recent mayoral elections have ended up in court after municipal and prefectural election commissions disagreed on who won them. With the country’s public offices election law setting no clear standard for judging such ballots, one expert is calling for wider use of electronic voting. Results Overturned In a two-way mayoral race in Kamisu, Ibaraki Prefecture, eastern Japan, in November 2025, then Mayor Susumu Ishida and challenger Toshiyuki Kiuchi received exactly the same number of votes. Kiuchi was declared the winner after lots were drawn. The city election commission recounted the ballots and upheld the result, but Ishida’s camp appealed to the prefectural election commission. The prefectural commission invalidated two handwritten ballots that had been counted for Kiuchi because they referred to a Japanese confectionery shop owner, with entries such as “manju-ya” (manju shop owner), rather than naming him. Manju is a steamed bun with a sweet filling. The commission then nullified Kiuchi’s victory. Kiuchi sued, arguing that his family runs a long-established Japanese confectionery shop. In September this year, however, Tokyo High Court upheld the commission’s decision, saying that “it cannot be determined clearly” that the phrases entered in the controversial ballots “were customarily used in place of his real name.” Remaining in office pending a final ruling, Kiuchi has appealed to the Supreme Court. He calls the ruling unacceptable because no other candidate had any connection to a Japanese confectionery shop. In the town of Nasu, Tochigi Prefecture, eastern Japan, the incumbent mayor won a March election this year by a single vote. The losing candidate appealed to the prefectural election commission, which then ruled in June that ballots combining one candidate’s surname with the other’s given name were valid, because the voter’s choice could be identified from the surname. On that basis, it reversed the result. In October, however, Tokyo High Court rejected the commission’s reasoning. It said that it was “hardly possible to decide which candidate’s full name had been written” on those ballots, and it overturned the result once again. The commission chose not to appeal. Push for Electronic Voting In Japanese elections, voters are generally required to write the name of their chosen candidate or political party by hand on the ballot paper. An alternative method, in which voters mark their choice on a ballot preprinted with the names of candidates or parties, is not widely used. One reason is concern that the order in which names appear could give certain candidates or parties an unfair advantage. Under the public offices election law, a ballot bearing the name of anyone other than a candidate is invalid. However, the law also requires that a ballot be treated as valid if it is clear which candidate the voter intended to vote for. “Circumstances vary from region to region, so it’s difficult to set uniform criteria,” said Harumichi Yuasa, a professor of information law at Meiji University and an expert on the election law. “As long as voters have to write candidates’ names by hand, there will always be ballots whose validity is in question.” Yuasa called electronic voting, in which voters choose a candidate on a tablet screen, “a practical alternative to handwritten ballots,” as it would effectively eliminate ambiguous ballots. It would also lighten the workload of municipal election staff and reduce paper use, he added. Japan has allowed electronic voting in elections for local government heads and assembly members since 2002. In 2003, however, equipment malfunctions during a city assembly election in Kani, Gifu Prefecture, central Japan, eventually led to the election being invalidated. Adoption of the system then stalled. In 2020, the internal affairs ministry relaxed its requirements so that tablets and other devices could be used. Since then, more municipalities have introduced electronic voting, including Shijonawate in Osaka Prefecture and Zentsuji in Kagawa Prefecture, both in western Japan. Nasu, where disputed ballots caused confusion in the March election, plans to introduce the system next year. High costs remain an obstacle. The ministry is encouraging municipalities to adopt the system by allocating special tax revenue grants. “There are challenges, including costs and support for older voters who are unfamiliar with electronic devices,” Yuasa said. “It’s important to build up a track record.” END [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.]
